The Mad Scene at the Capitol Today

Don't let this picture fool you. Things are craaazy down at the Capitol today.

Check out this video which captures throngs of the health care bill's opponents going through security earlier this afternoon. (via Wonkette)



Yowsas!

Photo courtesy of Dana Barciniak, Senior Photographer, U.S. House of Representatives Office of Photography.

Virginia Residents Making Health Care Personal on Capitol Hill

Yesterday, I tagged along with the Virginia Organizing Project (VOP) and residents from all over Virginia as they visited Capitol Hill to share their personal health care stories with their Senators and Representatives. As Kevin Simowitz, a VOP organizer, said to the group before their scheduled meetings:

"They [Congress] get lobbied all the time, right? Our estimates show that the insurance lobby spends about $641,000-a-day lobbying Congress. Now, we can pass a plate, but we're probably not gonna come up with that much money. The thing that we can do is you all can bring your personal stories about why we're here and why we need a public health insurance option as part of the bill. And if you're speaking out of your own experiences, speaking in non-partisan language, and speaking about what needs to happen... we're gonna walk out of this meeting a little bit further along the health care road than where we are."

We will have a video report for you on Monday, but for today I will share with you what these meetings were like and what was discussed.

The day started off at Senator Mark Warner's office where the group of some 20 people met with Luke Albee, Sen. Warner's Cheif of Staff (CoS). The group began the conversation by asking Mr. Albee for a legislative update on the health care fight from his perspective. "We're further along in health care than we've been in my life." We hear this all the time, but to this 25-year-old, that statement continues to move me. This fight is so much older than I am and we are so close to taking a huge step forward for our nation. "I think at the end of the day we're gonna get there," Mr. Albee added. "You guys have helped us a lot, because we are hearing from folks." He went on to say that during the stimulus fight they were only hearing from the other side, that it felt like the calls were 99 to 1 against and it hurt, but on health care both sides have been vocal.

The group then took some time to share personal stories about our health care system with the CoS. They started with Matt Masterson. Matt is a father of 3. He has Rheumatoid arthritis, his wife suffers from depression and had a near-fatal, enlarged gall bladder, and one of his children was diagnosed with juvenile diabetes at age 2. He had great insurance, but struggled to cover his son who has a preexisting condition. Matt mostly struggled with the costs though. Even with decent insurance, the copays for medication for his family became too much to take, eating $1,500-a-month at points. Then Matt lost his job for taking too much sick time. The costs became crippling to his family. His family lost their home and car. He explained all this to Mr. Albee, then began to tear up as he said, "I'm not doing this for me, I'm doing it for my kids... I want them not to have to go through what I went through... I got drove into poverty."

They continued sharing stories with Mr. Albee. Linda Pallette told about her battle with breast cancer. She had no insurance when this happened. She calls herself "lucky" that she did not own a home at the time, if she had, she would not have qualified for state hospitalization. It has now been 10 years since her successful fight with breast cancer, "I can never repay these 10 years... that's why I'm doing this... I'm okay. This is not about me." She then shared another story. This was of her neighbor's dear friend, who Linda only knew as Mary. Mary, when facing illness, literally chose to die rather than leave her family in medical debt.

Mr. Albee urged the group to continue knocking on doors, getting people to write letters and call the Senator's Office. The meeting ended with a group photo and an assurance from Mr. Albee that he would relate these stories and the others to Sen. Warner as thoroughly as possible.

Next on the list was Senator Jim Webb. The group met with Courtney Weaver, a Legislative Correspondent from Sen. Webb's office. The meeting was very similar to the previous one, a legislative update from Ms. Weaver, followed by personal stories, a request that she relate the stories to the Senator, and, of course, a photo with the group. And then it was off to the Representatives, Glenn Nye, Rob Wittman, and Eric Cantor to be exact. I tagged along with the group visiting Rep. Nye, who has said of the public option:

"I will consider the notion of a public option," Nye said, "... if it can be set up in such a way that it does not crowd out the private insurance market. That reduces choice, not increases it."

The group chose Rep. Nye because of this shaky support of the public option. The VOP believe this is a Representative that they can move. While Rep. Nye's office hears from insurance lobbyists, and opponents to reform, they are also hearing personal stories of struggle from members of his district. And to the Senators' and Representatives' credit, they are making time for their office to hear these stories. This plan, focusing on personal stories, is how health care reform advocates are fighting to cross the finish line.

Check back at Sum of Change on Monday for our video coverage of the day's events

Training Tuesday with the DFA: Recruiting Volunteers

This week, Training Tuesday will focus on another very important constituency: volunteers. As an organizer, building a strong volunteer base is your most important responsibility. The quality and quantity of the effort you get from your volunteers can make or break a campaign. They not only are giving you work for free (but don't tell them this!! See 'seizing an opportunity' below) but they are your direct representative to your most important constituency: voters. So their work is not only necessary, it must be done to a high standard and you must take it upon yourself to insure they are up to the task. From the Democracy for America (DFA) training manual:

You are a leader. Your job is to get your staff and volunteers to follow you. You set the tone. An energetic and enthusiastic leader will beget a focused and motivated volunteer base."

Our videos today will cover some of the basics of recruiting volunteers and building a lasting network. The DFA is truly an authority on this subject, so without further ado...

--Be Happy When You Ask For Volunteers


--Volunteers Are Seizing an Opportunity, Not Doing You a Favor


--The Volunteer Ask and the 5 Cs


That's all for this week. Don't forget to check back at the Sum of Change Training Tuesday page next week at 6:00pm for Matt Blizek's tips on how to run an effective email program!

Living a Double Life - Organizing in Second Life

One of the niche treats that we haven't yet shared from Netroots Nation 2009 in Pittsburgh was a panel we attended on Second Life, an online alternative universe where members create a 3d digital version of themselves, called an avatar, to live in a virtual world, that appears and operates much like our actual one. For the record I have never participated myself and probably never will, but the creative possibilities of Second Life are quite fascinating. By creating this realistic virtual world, Second Life allows people to express themselves in a world very similar to our own that they never could do in the real one. This gets played out in the creation of the avatar, for example, where one can build their appearance however they see fit, whether as an exact representation of themselves, a foil of themselves, or a dream character who they could never be in real life.

Personally I think it's nerdishly cool but pretty absurd and bizarre. Like Twitter, Second Life can be (and often is) used for personal superficial reasons, but also can be vehicles to build communities that address important social issues. Some waste time on twitter as a popularity contest, to build as many followers as possible and share every mundane insignificant detail of your life with the rest of the world, while others use it as a tool to build relationships and spread important information across the world. Anyone on twitter in the weeks after the Iran election will remember the green avatars, switching your hometown to Tehran, flooding the #IranElection and other various hashtags to make more traffic for Iranian officials to sort through while trying to locate protesters. Similarly, Second Life can be used to create an avatar that succumbs to all the excesses of life without the earthly consequences or one can use the Second Life character to make statements and connections surrounding important issues affecting the real world.

The people in these videos clearly fall into the latter category. In a variety of ways, their Avatars have taken creative but otherwise impossible actions in Second Life to confront important real world issues. They have taken advantage of the social networking possibilities Second Life offers and, in their own unique way, are taking a digital stand on actual issues...

--Connecting Second Life With Real World Small Organizations

--Second LIfe as an Immersive Educational Opportunity

--Second Life an Opportunity for Satyrical Commentary

--Building Communities with Interactive Experiences

For more videos from Netroots Nation 2009, go to www.SumofChange.com/NetrootsNation.

Brought to you by Sum of Change

Training Tuesday: 'Your Field Plan: Vote Goals, Targeting, and Field Strategy' from the DFA Campaign Academy

This week, we have a few clips from another session at Democracy For America (DFA) Campaign Academy's 'Grassroots Campaign Training' held September 26th and 27th at Gettysburg College in Gettysburg, PA. This session, called 'Your Field Plan: Vote Goals, Targeting, and Field Strategy', explains how a campaign can best prepare their own operation for electoral success by creating a specific and detailed field plan. According to DFA:

The field plan is the campaign's blueprint for victory. The field plan is the series of strategies and tactics a campaign uses to gather the necessary votes to win an election. The media plan, the finance plan, and all the campaign's administrative capacity serves one goal: support an operation capable of gathering the number of votes necessary to win the campaign. The field plan is that operation.

To this end, we have three clips for you. In the first, our new trainer, Kendra-Sue Derby, a longtime progressive campaign manager and advisor, explains how it is 'All About the Numbers'. As obvious as it sounds, the best way to win a campaign is to have the most voters, so keeping a plan of every voter and voting district and working off of that plan is the best way to win your campaign. In the next two videos, Kendra-Sue discusses some specific of how to best implement your plan by 'Targeting Your Voters'. In part one she outlines how a campaign should classify different kinds of potential voters while in part two she goes into how to approach, or not approach, each group...







For more information about the DFA Campaign Academy trainings, go to http://www.democracyforamerica.com/training. Unfortunately, the 2009 training season has ended, but you can contact DFA about having one in your area in 2010.

Please check out our Training Tuesday page for more Campaign Academy content, and come back every Tuesday @ 6:00 for more Training Tuesday videos.

Face-to-Face Encouragement: VOP at the Metro wth Rep Connoly Cutout

Last week, the Virginia Organizing Project (VOP) and Democracy for America (DFA) took to the metro with Representative Gerry Connelly, well, a cutout of him anyway. Volunteers asked passing metro riders if they would like to take a picture with the cutout for fun, and make a call to Representative Connolly and Senator Warner in support of a public option and a health care reform bill. The event made for some great hangin-with-Connolly interviews (with some unexpected street-side musical accompaniment) ...

The cutout, albeit fun to pose with, was there to send a very serious message to the Representative and other elected officials who are waffling on their support for a Public Option backed health care reform bill. It was an expression of frustration on the part of the DFA and VOP that Rep. Connolly appears to listen mostly to wealthy industry lobbyists, while ordinary citizens are forced to settle for a cutout. They feel that it is too important of an issue for a representative of the people to passivly decide upon and they want their congressmen to take an active role in ensuring its swift passage. This debate has gone on for an exceedingly long amount of time, but as the fight to pass a health care reform bill finally near the finish line, the DFA and VOP appear strong in their resolve to ensure a passage of a healthcare reform bill with a public option.

VOP uploaded a bunch of their pictures from the afternoon to their Flickr site, which we have included below...

Stand for Marriage Maine Plagiarizes Sum of Change

Apparently, the anti-gay marriage lobby isn't big on producing original material these days.

This morning, Sum of Change was startled to discover that video we shot at Netroots Nation this past August is being featured, unattributed, in a television advertisement for the 'Yes on 1' campaign produced by Stand for Marriage Maine. (We chose not to link to the commercial in question, "They Said", we would prefer if people did not watch it)

Stand for Marriage Maine uses our video to falsely suggest that gay rights groups are backtracking on what they paint as a 2005 promise not to pursue the legalization of gay marriage. The ad quotes Pat Peard, leader of Maine Won’t Discriminate, as saying that gay rights legislation "has nothing to do with marriage." The ad then shows Sum of Change's footage of Maine Equality's Monique Hoeflinger stating that her organization's 'No on 1' campaign, which works in exact opposition to 'Yes on 1,' had in fact been fighting for marriage equality since 2005.

Not only is this assertion false, Stand for Marriage Maine does not have the right to the footage and even went so far as to cut out Sum of Change’s logo.

While initially outraged by the theft of our material, we are more disturbed that Sum of Change is in any way associated with Stand for Marriage Maine. What 'Yes on 1' fails to realize is that marriage in a religious sense and marriage equality are two very different things. Peard's claim is that the gay rights debate has little to do with changing the religious institution of marriage but rather awarding the civil rights associated with marriage to gay couples, a conversation in which Maine Equality has indeed been honorably engaged since 2005.

In fact, this sentiment was echoed by Portland Democratic Party chair Sive Neilan. "I think everybody should have equal rights," Neilan told reporters at a rally in April. "[The legislation] has nothing to do with . . . marriage."

Sum of Change immediately issued a cease and desist request to Stand for Marriage Maine, but Zachary S. Kester and Barry A. Bostromm, the organization's attorneys, seems fairly nonplussed by our threat to pursue legal action. Kester is also the chair of the Christian Legal Society. Kester and Bostromm responded with a terse message to Sum of Change:

“Attached is Stand for Marriage Maine PAC's response to your cease and decist request. Any further communications regarding this or any other communication by Stand of Marriage Maine PAC are to be directed to this office.”

Apparently, Mr. Kester and Mr. Bostromm don’t know how to spell ‘desist’ (or ‘decist,’ as he puts it), nor are they aware that the organization they represent is called ‘Stand for Marriage Maine’ and not ‘Stand of Marriage Maine.’ We’re betting neither are the utmost authority on copyright law, either.

In the attached statement, Kester and Bostromm stood by Stand for Marriage Maine’s refusal to take down Sum of Change's footage:

“No permission was required and no permission was sought from Sum of Change Productions, LLC, for use of a very short segment of the gay right summit video, which was filmed at a conference of gay marriage supporters on August 13, 2009.”

Wrong again, Mr. Kester and Mr. Bostromm. The "conference of gay marriage supporters" at which we filmed the "gay right summit video" was, in fact, Netroots Nation, a political convention for American progressive political activists which addresses a wide range of topics. Though gay rights were indeed discussed at this year's conference, a few panelists speaking on behalf of gay rights does not a “gay right summit” make. Sum of Change has difficulty finding confidence in Mr. Kester’s legal assessment when he struggles to correctly define the nature of Netroots Nation.

(Sum of Change feels the need to point out that the gay community is pursuing gay rights, plural, not a "gay right," singular, as Mr. Kester and Mr. Bostromm put it.)

Also, the fair use doctrine under federal copyright law which Stand for Marriage Maine cites as its legal reasoning does not allow the organization to claim authorship of material. By failing to cite Sum of Change as the author of the footage in question, Stand for Marriage Maine implies ownership in an exhibition of blatant plagiarism.

Not surprisingly, this is not the first time Stand for Marriage Maine has run into trouble for stealing material. National Public Radio is currently pursuing legal action against the organization for using audio from an NPR radio show in television spots without permission. Gee, that doesn’t sound familiar.

Scott Fish, Director of Communications for the ‘Yes on 1’ campaign, called NPR’s claim a “ridiculous and frivolous complaint." However, when asked about the use of Sum of Change’s footage in a similar commercial, Fish played dumb and claimed not to have any knowledge of the television commercial whatsoever.

Sum of Change is currently considering legal action against Stand for Marriage Maine. We will continue to update the site with developments.